5. Eaton

The details of Manitoba’s entry into confederation, the issuance of scrip to the Métis, and the subsequent land rush are all well beyond the scope of this story (see "further reading" below for a good summary of the scrip system). For our purposes, suffice it to say that after Manitoba became the fifth province in 1870, migration from Eastern Canada and overseas increased dramatically. Winnipeg’s population grew from 241 in 1871 to 7,995 in 1881 and 26,529 in 1891. Some of this was because the city expanded its boundaries (this area was officially annexed by the city in 1882), incorporating new residents, but the vast majority of the population growth was due to the deluge of newcomers from outside of Manitoba. With these migrants came an army of real estate speculators - hundreds from Ontario alone - eager to profit on what they anticipated would soon become very valuable land, especially once the railway arrived. One of these speculators was William Case Eaton (sadly, no relation to Timothy).

Eaton was born in 1847 in Carlisle, just outside Burlington, Ontario. He moved to Winnipeg in 1873 to join a survey party. At that time many prime properties were still owned by the Métis title holders. The real “land rush” didn’t hit until 1881-82. By 1910 only ~10% of Métis still owned their land. A lot of it was lost through scams and coercive means, including onerous property tax burdens leading to tax sales. Some Métis also decided to sell because the explosive growth of the city threatened their way of life. Many of these moved west to what is now Saskatchewan and Alberta.

We have no way of knowing specifically what induced Pierre Allary to sell lots 58 and 59 to William Case Eaton on August 25, 1875, but we do have all the associated documents. The sale price was $750 and “a good horse” valued at $125. $750 is roughly $25,000 in today’s dollars, or to put it in terms of 1875 purchasing power, apparently the cost of six good horses. As another point of comparison, labour wages were about $1 a day. The property was 192 acres in total, and the Dominion Lands Act of 1872 pegged land at $1 per acre for the calculation of scrip value, so from that perspective, it may have seemed like a good deal. But Eaton knew that it would soon be worth far more. 


Eaton sold a right of way to the CPR (now the BNSF tracks) for $450 in 1881, and in 1913 he received $3000 from the city for Godfrey Avenue (now called Academy Road). Inflation was only about 20% between 1875 and 1913, so by that he had already made an excellent profit on the original purchase price. And that was before the real money started rolling in. Eaton sold more road easements to the city for $32,000 in 1920, and the school district bought land from him for $7000 in 1921. Then in 1925, he began to subdivide the land into building lots. I only have access to the city title transfers for our property, and these records do not include the sale price. However, the bottom end of the market in 1925 was $80 per foot of frontage (which is how building lots were valued then), and Eaton owned at least 15,000 feet. You can do the math. 

Margaret & William Eaton (1885)

Sources and Further Reading:

"Métis Scrip in Canada." The Canadian Encyclopedia. https://thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/metis-scrip-in-canada

City of Winnipeg Archives accessed through a title search. Documents available on request.




Comments

Popular Posts